Skip to Main Content
Straight from New York Bagels logo topStraight from New York Bagels logo scroll
  • Facebook pageInstagram pageYelp page
  • Menu
  • Drinks
  • Specials
  • Events
  • Order
  • Catering
  • Gift Cards

Our Menu

BagelsLunchBreakfast

Bagels

Plain

Poppy

Sesame

Everything

Salt

Pumpernickel

$2.00

Onion

Garlic

Egg

Egg Everything

Cinnamon Raisin

Honey Wheat

Powerhouse

Bialy

Flagel

JalapeƱo Cheddar

Asiago

French Toast

Bagel Toppings

Butter

Grape Jelly

Butter & Jelly

Strawberry Preserves

Butter & Preserves

PB & J

Cream Cheeses

Plane

Scallion

Vegetable

Strawberry

Honey Walnut

CC & Jelly

CC & Preserves

Salmon

Bagels by The Bag

Half Dozen

Doze (15) Bagels

Dozen +2 Spreads

Cold Sandwiches

Homemade Salads

Made with Hellman's Mayo choice of Tuna, Chicken or Egg served on wheat berry bread

Ham & Cheese

Ham and Swiss cheese served on a Kaiser roll

Turkey and Swiss

Turkey and Swiss Cheese served on a Kaiser roll
BLT photo

BLT

Apple-wood or smoked bacon lettuce ripe tomato mayo served on country white toast

Roast Beef and Cheddar

Slow cooked store made premium Angus roast beef with age cheddar cheese, horseradish sauce serve on a Kaiser roll
Italian photo

Italian

Salami, pepperoni, ham, provolone cheese, lettuce, ripe tomato, onion, cherry pepper serve on a sub roll with Store made sub dressings.

Hot Sandwiches

Jersey Shore Grilled Cheese photo

Jersey Shore Grilled Cheese

American cheese tomato and applewood smoked bacon served on country whole bread
New York Cheese Steak photo

New York Cheese Steak

Slow cook store made premium shaved top ground grilled with peppers and onions topped with a provolone cheese served on a grilled sub roll
Chicken Bacon Ranch photo

Chicken Bacon Ranch

Grilled chicken applewood smoked bacon ranch dressing with lettuce and tomato on a sub roll
Ruben photo

Ruben

Half pound piled high slow cooked corn beef with Swiss cheese sauerkraut 1000 island dressing on grilled seeded rye
New Yorker photo

New Yorker

Half pound piled high slow cooked corn beef and pastrami with swiss cheese on grilled seeded rye with deli mustard
West Ender photo

West Ender

Half pound piled high pastrami with swiss cheese served on grilled seeded rye and deli mustard

Fresh Salads

Caesar Salad

Fresh chopped romaine lettuce Parmesan cheese store made croutons Caesar dressing add grilled chicken

Garden Salad

Fresh iceberg lettuce with mixed greens ripe tomato cucumber onion store made croutons choice of dressings

Side Dishes

Potato Salad

Cole Slaw

Pasta Salad

Assorted Chips

Breakfast Sandwiches

All sandwiches served on your choice of Bagel or White, Wheat Rye, Kaiser or Croissant

Bacon Egg & Cheese

Sausage Egg & Cheese photo

Sausage Egg & Cheese

Ham Egg & Cheese

Pork Roll Egg & Cheese

Steak, Egg & Cheese photo

Steak, Egg & Cheese

Egg & Meat

Egg & Steak

Extras

Chicken Sausage available

Egg

Meat

Cheese

Add Tomato

Add Butter

Muffins

Made fresh daily All Muffins | Muffins and baked goods selections may vary daily

Blueberry

Cranberry

Cinnamon Chip

Chocolate Chip

Black Cherry

  • Order
  • Catering